Quite a few icons, that have circles with r<1 ∧ r!=0.75

[quantenzitrone]

most of these are probably errors, some may be intentional:

0.8507 : _1xbit.svg
0.7999 : _5_in_1.svg
0.7472 : _1822_direkt.svg
0.7742 : act_fibernet.svg
0.7506 : agoda.svg
0.825 : aircare.svg
0.7 : amazon_music.svg
0.7 : amazon_prime_video.svg
0.7821 : aplayer.svg
0.7472 : appmgr_iii.svg
0.7 : apps2fire.svg
0.9286 : aranet.svg
0.7 : ariane2.svg
0.8 : asn_bankieren.svg
0.8 : bolt.svg
0.5566 : chimera_recollect.svg
0.3701 : chrono_trigger.svg
0.7499 : circloo.svg
0.8 : cnn_turk.svg
0.9042 : coffee_golf.svg
0.7472 : coindcx_bitcoin.svg
0.775 : coingecko.svg
0.8336 : combide.svg
0.5 : concentricclock.svg
0.3331 : darkmodelivewallpaper.svg
0.4792 : digiturk_online.svg
0.4792 : digiturk_play.svg
0.4792 : digiturk_sinyal.svg
0.7502 : ditmm.svg
0.8 : droidvim.svg
0.8 : dslrdashboard.svg
0.7488 : ecoledirecte.svg
0.7 : firetv.svg
0.7517 : flic.svg
0.7472 : flip_transfer.svg
0.25 : foss_warn.svg
0.7198 : fritz_app_wlan.svg
0.5209 : genshin_impact.svg
0.71 : gif_live_wallpaper.svg
0.8 : hamradiotools.svg
0.7 : hepsiburada.svg
0.9 : hidemevpn.svg
0.5 : i2pd.svg
0.795 : incognitowallet.svg
0.8 : isotopebrowser.svg
0.8 : istegelsin.svg
0.7 : jersey_mikes.svg
0.9774 : keyoxide.svg
0.66 : kinoteatr.svg
0.5867 : kitchenowl.svg
0.948 : koton.svg
0.8 : landroid.svg
0.3788 : libary.svg
0.675 : liftago.svg
0.7496 : like_a_dino.svg
0.8 : mathtricks.svg
0.7 : mavi.svg
0.8734 : metrictime.svg
0.7842 : michelin.svg
0.634 : monefy.svg
0.9666 : money_lover.svg
0.8 : moneywallet.svg
0.7319 : monpetitgazon.svg
0.9508 : moon_phase.svg
0.65 : myswordforandroid.svg
0.692 : nafath.svg
0.8364 : nothing_weather.svg
0.7501 : opsu_.svg
0.9873 : orloj.svg
0.7499 : pccovid.svg
0.9552 : plant_vs_zombie_2.svg
0.9552 : plants_vs_zombies.svg
0.8569 : pocket_fm.svg
0.7502 : printbot.svg
0.7497 : pubg_mobile.svg
0.5 : pulseaudiortpreceiver.svg
0.7498 : quick_dice_roller.svg
0.82 : rabbitescape.svg
0.7499 : reuters.svg
0.8409 : rtrnettest.svg
0.795 : samsungpaymini.svg
0.7 : sanitas_portal.svg
0.3 : setedit.svg
0.8 : shadereditor.svg
0.4692 : soulknight.svg
0.5 : stellarium.svg
0.5 : stellariumfree.svg
0.6423 : tiny_planet_fx_pro.svg
0.9401 : toon_blast.svg
0.7905 : tpbank_etoken.svg
0.9 : trainline.svg
0.2103 : tribal_wars.svg
0.7498 : uno.svg
0.7532 : verkehr_nrw.svg
0.7 : videlibri.svg
0.795 : virginmoney.svg
0.7659 : vtv_go.svg
0.73 : yourphone.svg

Total count: 98

Script to get this result (fish shell):

for i in *
    set r (cat $i | grep -Po '<circle .*?>' | grep -o 'r="[0]*\.[0-9]*' | cut -c 4- | sed 's/^\./0./g' | head -n1)
    if test "$r" != "" && test "$r" != "0.75"
        echo $r : $i
    end
end

[TotallyAvailable]

Besides the 'E' sticking out more than necessary, Verkehr.NRW would absolutely get a seal of approval from me.

Isotopebrowser is difficult.

There are a few more but I think that's not the point (of personal opinions), guidelines exist for a reason.
Should a few be left as is, if so who decides, certainly not me.

Also thanks for bringing it up in such a condensed form.
Might feed into #1804

[Donnnno]

I had my suspicions, 1,5px should be the case for every icon.

[quantenzitrone]

bruh

[quantenzitrone]

Actually, all non-filled dots with sizes above 0.5 have a hole (assuming all icons have line-width=1px correctly), and thus are valid.

[quantenzitrone]

for example the smaller dots here have r=0.929

[quantenzitrone]

oh shit some of the wrong-dot-radius-icons are my doing 😬

[Donnnno]

Nothing wrong with the last example, right?

[Donnnno]

oh shit some of the wrong-dot-radius-icons are my doing 😬

Same for me 😅

[TotallyAvailable]

Sounds like a "The reworkening" incoming.
I also can no longer unsee the issue with the Foss Warn dot...

[quantenzitrone]

Nothing wrong with the last example, right?

yes it was an example of r<1 being acceptable

[Kaiserdragon2]

I had my suspicions, 1,5px should be the case for every icon.

the thing is the script checks the radius and the 1.5px is the width and height